A Tale of Two Viogniers

Jen’s Notes

Miner Family, Simpson Vineyard 2006
$16.99

Boy, was I skeptical about this one, chiefly because everyone and their cousin think it's the best California Viognier ever. Hah.

As I learned, however, they are probably right.

This wine is dry, but ripe, and almost bafflingly complex as a result. Scents of Bananas Foster draw you in, after which your palate will reel at a parade of flavors, including herbs, florals and a hint of guava underneath. The finish is clean and dry at first, but lengthened as the wine opened up. At its peak, the finish was medium-length with a lingering richness.

Excellent, and an astounding value.

Cline, Los Carneros, 2006
$16.00

This was the one for which I'd reserved my higher hopes. It was sweeter than the Miner, and less complex to boot. With its juicy pear flavor and a longish finish, the best I can say is that it is pleasant, and go buy the Miner next time.